top of page

Our Recent Posts

Archive

Tags


The Man Who Owned No Land, But Gave Us Ours: A Review of the Krumbiegel Commemoration at NGMA


The National Gallery of Modern Art (NGMA) auditorium in Bengaluru did not merely reach capacity; it overflowed.


By the time the lights dimmed for the screening of Ganesh Shankar Raj’s documentary, The Maharaja’s German Gardener, the room was bursting. An additional 30 to 40 chairs lined the aisles, and every deep bay window was occupied by citizens perched to get a glimpse.

This massive turnout was the first profound realization of the evening: generations later, Bengaluru still shows up for its green heritage. Watching the livestream from afar, Gustav Hermann Krumbiegel’s great-granddaughter, Alyia Krumbiegel—who carries her ancestor’s torch with fierce devotion—shared her deep emotion:

"Tonight’s screening for my great grandfather in Bangalore has left me deeply emotional. I was quietly worried not many people would come, and to see a full room, with people gathering in every corner just to listen and remember, means more than I can ever put into words. A legacy only truly lives on when people still care enough to show up for it generations later. Tonight, Bangalore did. 🌿 Thank you."


From Kew to Karnataka: The Visionary We Took for Granted


Organized by Heritage Beku, the Friday evening of 22 May 2026 masterfully bridged the gap between historical gratitude and urgent, future-forward civic action. The documentary traceed the staggering journey of a 19-year-old German youth who traveled from the Royal Botanic Gardens at Kew to Baroda, and finally to the red soil of Mysore and Bangalore.


We often view Krumbiegel through a purely botanical lens, but the film and subsequent panel discussion shattered that narrow view. GHK was an urban planner, an economist, and a humanitarian. Long before modern governance structures existed, he was installing farmers' ponds, establishing sustainable fisheries, and creating localized economic security for rural communities. He introduced agricultural diversity as a precursor to the very technological, gender, and economic diversity that defines Bengaluru as a global hub today.


Furthermore, as NGMA Director Priyanka Francis noted in her closing thanks, many in the room were astonished to learn the sheer breadth of his architectural and landscaping footprint—including his design contributions to iconic civic landmarks like the BBMP building and Jayanagar's Janatha Bazaar.


The Poignancy of an Outsider’s Devotion


Yet, for a man who orchestrated the symphonic, multi-colored canopy of our city, the true history of his final years left the auditorium in a heavy, collective silence.


Despite his deep reverence for local royalty and Indian citizens, geopolitical tides were cruel to Krumbiegel. He was interned as an "enemy alien" during both World Wars simply for his German birth. To the British, he was the Maharaja’s man; to the changing landscape of post-Independence India, he was a disposable relic of an old order.


When his formal tenure ended, this visionary was unceremoniously bundled into a small outhouse at Jayamahal Palace. Though his letters always proudly listed his address as Lalbagh—his true crowning jewel—he found himself in a brand-new country (Independent India) building itself from the bottom up, with no official place for him. He was given a heartbreaking two-day marching order to vacate and return to Germany, prompting a sorrowful final letter to his close friend, the Diwan of Mysore.


He stayed, and when he passed away at 90, he was laid to rest in a small, largely unmarked grave in the Indian Christian Cemetery on Hosur Road—just one of a hundred weathering headstones. Shortly after, his grieving wife Clara was given 2 days notice to vacate their quarters; she suffered a fatal stroke upon reaching England.


It is a profound, tragic irony: the man who designed the very identity of Bengaluru owned no land of his own within it. He was owned by no one . Not Germany which he left at 18, or Britain where he devoted 10 years at Kew (and married a British wife Clara) before coming in to Varoda and India at 28. He lived on an annual salary of just ₹600, remaining a legal outsider in every space he radically transformed.


The Panel: Turning Memory into Momentum


Following the film, the panel discussion dynamically connected this historical debt to concrete plans for Bengaluru’s ecological survival. There was a moment of silence remembering the selfless man and brilliant visionary -with no country- who gave us our city of joy.


1. Mr. R. Girish, IAS (Secretary of Horticulture) on Policy & Green Corridors

Mr. Girish brought administrative reality to the stage, suggesting the structural implementation of dedicated green corridors to combat growing urban heat islands.


The discussion shifted to the urgent need to overhaul municipal policy. A major loophole was spotlighted: the current system allows for online tree-cutting applications, and penalties for illegal felling are often compoundable (settlable with a minor fine). The panel and audience strongly advocated for making tree-cutting penalties non-compoundable, carrying mandatory prison time. Tightening these legal screws is the only way to deter illegal felling by commercial developers.


2. Suresh Jayaram (Art Historian & Author) on Historical Truth

Suresh grounded the conversation in the artistic genius of Krumbiegel’s "serial blossom"—the intentional choreography of flowering trees so the city changes color season by season.

He also brought a moment of witty relief to the room. When an audience member joked that the spelling on "Krumbiegel Road" is notoriously botched by city municipal workers, a panelist quipped that many locals genuinely believe "Krumbiegel" is a native name from North Karnataka. The consensus? Perhaps we should leave the spelling mistakes alone and let North Karnataka proudly claim him too!


3. Ganesh Shankar Raj (Filmmaker) on Educational Connects

Ganesh emphasized that the film must not stop at cultural auditoriums. He laid out plans to take the documentary directly into schools and colleges to foster an emotional, ecological connection within the younger generation.

The audience enthusiastically backed this, calling for a major youth outreach push ahead of Krumbiegel’s birthday this December.

Reclaiming the Space: The Revival of Traffic-Free Cubbon Park


The energy in the room turned fiercely proactive when discussing Bengaluru’s immediate environmental future. The audience collectively demanded a revival of Heritage Beku’s highly successful campaign for a Traffic-Free Cubbon Park.


While the initiative previously faced pushback from the traffic department, the overwhelming consensus at NGMA was clear: it is time to push back harder. Protecting these historic green lungs from vehicle emissions is no longer an option; it is a necessity to lower the city's worsening microclimate temperatures.


The Manifesto: Giving Him Ownership

We breathe the oxygen his avenue trees multiplied. We walk beneath the explosion of canopies he imported like precious cargo from the far corners of the earth.


It is a historical injustice that G.H. Krumbiegel remains an unrecognized force. A misspelled street sign is not enough. A single statue is not enough.


Heritage Beku proposes three definitive steps to level the scales:


The Posthumous Honorary Citizenship: A formal, symbolic declaration by the State of Karnataka to claim G.H. Krumbiegel as a true son of the soil.

The Krumbiegel Memorial Bust: An artistic installation at the heart of his landscape to serve as an interactive educational space for children.

The Annual Krumbiegel Legacy Award: To honor local communities, lake-groups, and young climate warriors who preserve our urban canopy.

When he died, he had no country to call his own. It is time we change that. We have owned his work for a century; it is finally time to let him own us. Let us give him the ultimate, permanent goodbye: the status of a true, honored Bangalorean.


"In the end, we will conserve only what we love; we will love only what we understand; and we will understand only what we are taught."


— Baba Dioum


Let us teach our children who designed the Garden City, so they find the courage to save it. Bengaluru Beku—and our green heritage starts with us.

13 May 2026

Open Letter to the Govt: Free the Commons at Cubbon

 

The Soul of Bengaluru is Not for Sale: A Manifesto Against the Commodification of Cubbon Park


This is in response to the article in UdayVani proposing an entry fee for Cubbon Park .

As a collective of environmentalists, civic activists, and heritage custodians, we stand in resolute opposition to the proposed introduction of entrance fees at Sri Chamarajendra Park (Cubbon Park). This is not merely a debate about a nominal ticket price; it is a fundamental struggle for the identity of our city, the health of our ecosystems, and the integrity of our democracy.

For over 150 years, Cubbon Park has served as the egalitarian heart of Bengaluru. To put a price on its gates is to dismantle the very concept of "The Commons" and betray the trust of the citizens to whom this land belongs. As per earlier requests made by Heritage Beku , we need to renew our efforts now to definitively declare Cubbon Park as a Biodiversity Heritage Site .


1. A Park is Not a Museum: The Crisis of the Commons

There is a critical distinction that the administration seems to have overlooked: Cubbon Park is not a botanical garden; it is a People’s Park.

Unlike Lalbagh, which functions as a curated botanical repository for scientific study, Cubbon Park is a vital civic lung. As noted by Alyia Krumbiegel, great-granddaughter of the legendary G.H. Krumbiegel, a park is a living, breathing space meant for the worker seeking shade, the student seeking quiet, and the elderly seeking health.

  • The Barrier of Entry: Imposing a fee transforms a Citizen into a Customer.

  • The Death of Inclusivity: Where will the Aam Janta—the daily wage earners, the street vendors, and the marginalized families—go to escape the stifling heat and concrete of an exploding city?

  • A Dangerous Precedent: If we allow the "pay-to-breathe" model here, we signal that nature is a luxury for the elite rather than a fundamental right.


2. Ecological Integrity vs. Administrative Inertia

The justification for entry fees—purportedly to fund security and maintenance—is a factual fallacy. The issues plaguing the park are not a result of a lack of revenue potential, but a failure of governance and resource allocation.

  • Forgotten Promises: On October 27, 2025, Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar categorically promised the public that no entry fee would be charged. He acknowledged that the park’s budget (currently ₹8 crore) needs enhancement and promised a grant of ₹5 crore.

  • The Staffing Paradox: It is unsustainable to claim a security crisis when the existing park staff are diverted for census duties, leaving the "green jewel" both unmanned and unguarded.

  • Sustainability over Commercialization: We do not need ticket booths; we need:

    • A comprehensive water table study to preserve the park's longevity.

    • The designation of the park as a Biodiversity Site.

    • Strict enforcement of the traffic ban to reduce pollution and vibration damage to heritage structures.

"The true success of a public garden is not how controlled it becomes, but how deeply it is loved, respected and shared by ordinary people." — Alyia Krumbiegel


3. Democracy and the Right to the City

Public spaces are the bedrock of a functioning democracy. They are the only places where people from all walks of life intersect without the mediation of commerce.

By gating Cubbon Park, the government is effectively "punishing the many for the behaviour of a few." Security concerns and public behavior issues should be addressed through better management, CCTV infrastructure, and respectful enforcement, not by financial exclusion.


4. Our Demand: A Call for Accountability

We call upon the Department of Horticulture and the Government of Karnataka to honour the Deputy CM's public commitment. We suggest :

  1. Zero Entry Fees: Maintain the park as a free, open-access public space in perpetuity.

  2. Budgetary Transparency: Utilize the promised ₹5 crore grant for immediate infrastructure and staffing needs.

  3. Heritage Protection: Cease all commercial expansion and prioritize the restoration of the Bandstand and existing historical precincts.

  4. Community Governance: Establish a management committee that includes civic groups (like Heritage Beku and CPWA) to ensure the park is managed for people, not for profit.

Cubbon Park is our shared heritage. It was never intended to intimidate or separate; it was built to connect. We will not allow the gates of our 'Garden City' to be locked against its own people.


Signed, 

The Guardians of the Commons

Additional Note:

The Green Commons: Why Cubbon Park Must Remain Free to All


As an alliance of environmentalists, heritage custodians, and civic advocates, we are profoundly concerned by recent proposals to introduce entrance fees at Sri Chamarajendra Park (Cubbon Park). This proposal is not merely a budgetary adjustment; it is a direct assault on the democratic fabric of Bengaluru and the fundamental right of every citizen to access nature.

Below is our detailed analysis of the implications this move holds for our ecosystems, our heritage, and our civic identity.


I. Voices of the People: The Promise of Accessibility

Leaders and descendants of the park's own legacy have been clear: Cubbon Park is a public trust, not a commercial asset.

Deputy CM DK Shivakumar (Oct 2025): "Cubbon Park is open to the public. Anyone can visit... There is no proposal to collect an entry fee... This is a People’s Park." Source: Bangalore Mirror/Udayavani

Alyia Krumbiegel (G/granddaughter of GH Krumbiegel): "A botanical garden exists for study... but a public park is something far more democratic. A park belongs to the people. It is where children run freely... Bengaluru earned the name 'Garden City' because green spaces were woven into everyday life, not locked away from it."

Priya Chetty-Rajagopal (Heritage Beku): "Where will poor people go? This is so undemocratic... I disagree with any proposal to charge fees, because it is the only people’s park."


II. Global & National Standards: Great Cities Don't Charge for Breath

The world's greatest urban centers treat their central parks as "The Commons"—spaces that are essential for public health and are funded through taxes, not tickets. To charge for Cubbon Park would place Bengaluru outside the league of globally respected, livable cities.

Park Name

Location

Status

Heritage/Size

Lodi Gardens

Delhi, India

Free

The Maidan

Kolkata, India

Free

Central Park

New York, USA

Free

Hyde Park

London, UK

Free

Tiergarten

Berlin, Germany

Free


III. The Philosophers of the Commons

Global conservationists and urban planners have long argued that free access to nature is a prerequisite for a healthy society.

  • Frederick Law Olmsted (Designer of Central Park): He believed that the beauty of a park should be "the beauty of the fields... of the green pastures" and that it must provide a "sense of enlarged freedom" to those escaping the "cramped, confined, and controlling circumstances of the streets." Charging a fee reimposes those "controlling circumstances" at the very gate of relief.

  • Jane Jacobs (Urban Visionary): In The Death and Life of Great American Cities, Jacobs argued that public parks are "brilliant manifestations of democracy" only because they are owned and usable by anyone. Ticketing creates a "resource-sucking dead zone" by filtering out the very diversity that makes a park safe and vibrant.

  • John Muir (Conservationist): "Everybody needs beauty as well as bread, places to play in and pray in, where Nature may heal and cheer and give strength to body and soul alike."


IV. Implications on Ecosystems and Democracy

1. The Erosion of the Commons

When a public space is ticketed, the visitor is no longer a Citizen with a right; they become a Customer with an expectation. This shifts the management's focus from ecological preservation to "customer satisfaction," often leading to unnecessary "beautification" projects (paving, kiosks, lighting) that harm biodiversity.

2. Ecological Exclusion

Cubbon Park is a critical Micro-Climate Regulator. If the socio-economically disadvantaged are priced out, they are disproportionately affected by the "Urban Heat Island" effect. Democracy dictates that the cooling effects of 300 acres of canopy should not be a "premium service."

3. Administrative Failure vs. Civic Punishment

The argument for fees to fund "security and CCTV" is a redirection of responsibility.

  • The Budget Exists: The DCM promised an additional ₹5 crore grant.

  • Staffing Shortfall: It is a governance failure to send park staff on census duty and then ask citizens to pay for the resulting lack of security.


Conclusion

Cubbon Park is the soul of Bengaluru. To gate it is to tell the worker, the student, and the ordinary family that they are no longer welcome in the heart of their own city. We demand that the government honor its October 2025 commitment: Keep the gates open, keep the air free, and keep the democracy of our "Garden City" intact.


References:



1 Feb 2026

 

The Director,

Jawaharlal Nehru Planetarium (BASE),

High Grounds, Bengaluru – 560001.


Dear Dr. Guruprasad,


Subject: Proposal for "Past Forward" – A Community & Heritage Collaboration with The Planetarium


I hope this letter finds you well. Thank you for the chat we had and  your interest in this space and on being a stronger part of the local community.


I am writing to you on behalf of Heritage Beku, a citizen’s initiative dedicated to preserving the unique historical and cultural character of our city. As you know, we are deeply invested in connecting the citizens of Bengaluru with their roots, not just to celebrate the past, but to anchor our future.


We have long admired the Jawaharlal Nehru Planetarium for its tremendous impact on children and students, sparking curiosity about the cosmos in young minds. However, we see a wonderful, untapped opportunity to widen this circle of wonder to the adult community and the local residents of our vibrant neighbourhood—including Palace Road, Millers Road, Vasant Nagar, and the Raj Bhavan area.


Our Proposal: A "Past Forward" Quarterly Program While the planetarium is a gateway to the future, the study of the skies is also one of our oldest shared heritages. We propose collaborating on a special quarterly evening program designed specifically for adults and the local community.

  • The Theme: "Past Forward"—exploring how our understanding of the universe has shaped our history, culture, and future.

  • The Format: A conducive, relaxed setting where adults can engage with astronomy, perhaps linking it to Indian heritage (like the Jantar Mantar legacy) or modern "Dark Sky" conservation, followed by a sky-watch.

  • The Goal: To bridge the gap between "science for kids" and "lifelong wonder for adults," making the Planetarium a community anchor for all ages.


Community Integration We believe the Planetarium can be the beating heart of the Central Bangalore community. By engaging with local residents, schools, and colleges in a more direct, informal capacity, we can embed the institution as a caring, responsible, and integral part of our daily lives.


Formalizing the Partnership To take this forward, we would be delighted to sign an informal Letter of Understanding (LoU) or Collaboration with you. This would allow us to co-curate activities, drive community engagement, and bring a new demographic of enthusiastic citizens to your doorstep.


We are certain that this initiative will build on your existing success and position the Planetarium as a dynamic space where Heritage meets Science. We look forward to discussing this with you at the earliest.


Warm regards,


Priya Chetty Rajagopal 

Founder, Heritage Beku

 

Research: Global Best Practices & Similar Initiatives

To support our discussion , here are examples of how planetariums and heritage organisations worldwide are collaborating to engage adult audiences:

1. "Archaeoastronomy" & Heritage Walk

  • Concept: connecting ancient sites with astronomical significance.

  • Relevance: India has a rich history of astronomy (e.g., Jantar Mantar). A session on “How Bengaluru’s ancestors saw the sky” or “Indian Astronomy Heritage” would perfectly blend the missions of Heritage Beku and the Planetarium.

2. The "Museum Late" or "Star Party" Model

  • Global Practice: Institutions like the Griffith Observatory (Los Angeles) and Science Museum (London) host "Lates"—adult-only evenings with talks, music, and telescope viewings.

  • Local Adaptation: A quarterly "Star Party" at JNP for the Vasant Nagar/Millers Road community would foster a sense of ownership and neighbourliness.

3. "Dark Sky" Heritage Conservation

  • Trend: The International Dark-Sky Association works to protect the night sky as a shared heritage.

  • Idea: Heritage Beku could champion a "Dark Sky" awareness campaign in the Central Business District (CBD) to reduce light pollution, with the Planetarium as the technical expert. This positions the sky itself as a "heritage structure" worth saving.

4. Citizen Science Projects

  • Example: Galaxy Zoo allows citizens to help classify galaxies.

  • Idea: Launch a "Bengaluru Sky Watch" where locals contribute data on star visibility, blending community effort with scientific observation.

Blog: Blog

©2019 by #HeritageBeku.  All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page