top of page

Our Recent Posts

Archive

Tags


Pics courtesy Bangalore Mirror/Turquoise Cloud
The Koenigsberg designed building 1941. Now a library

26 Dec 2022


Mr. Chandrasekhar

DD- BBMP Horticulture

BBMP Head Office

Bangalore 560002


Dear Mr. Chandrashekar,


Sub: Construction at MN Krishna Rao Park


This is regarding the recent construction activity in MN Krishna Rai Park. My colleague Priya Chetty-Rajagopal had also been in touch with you and the Commissioner on this. We feel we should work closely together on natural heritage focus at BBMP Parks.


We are concerned by a few issues, and it would have been nice to have some public consultation also. We want to bring to your attention some issues with the park listed below. Most are easily actionable.


1. Entrances to the Park - There are three entrance gates to the park. At present, only the main entrance on Dewan Madhav Rao Road is open. Please keep all the entrances open during park hours. All the entrances are used by the people who come to the park.

2. Railings: re the addition of railings in a park, we are at a loss to understand the need for the railings on either side of the walking path.

3. Senior Citizen Friendly - There have been many incidents when senior citizens have tripped and fallen and had fractures on the loose pavers that were uprooted due to the roots. They were incorrectly laid close to the roots. Now, new pavers are being laid. We request you to ensure that they don’t loosen, and we request you to replace any loose pavers as part of the regular maintenance.

4. Senior citizen access - Many senior citizens have stopped coming to the park. The park hours and the rush hour on the surrounding streets coincide and senior citizens find it difficult to cross the streets during rush hour to enter the park. They get scared to cross with moving traffic. There are raised pedestrian crosswalks, but motorists don’t slow down for pedestrians. There have been a few accidents when people have tried to cross the road to go to the park. The residents on the surrounding streets and nearby areas have requested a traffic signal near the main entrance to the park on Dewan Madhav Rao Road. However, this request has not been considered. We request you to consider a traffic signal.

5. Park timings- We request you to extend the afternoon park hours by one hour so that the park can be used for additional time during daylight hours. We request you to change the park timings from 4 pm to 8 pm to 3 pm to 8 pm.

6. Cutting of trees - Lately, a lot of trees in the park are being cut. We request you to stop unnecessary cutting of trees. This is a beautiful park with natural amenities like trees, shrubs and plants. This natural beauty should be preserved.

7. Benches and dustbins - We request you to please replace the benches and dustbins that were removed.

8. Rose garden near Sri. M. N. Krishna Rao Statue - There are hardly any roses now. We request you to plant some rose bushes.

9. Children’s park - We congratulate you on the new additions and equipment for the children’s park. It is being used very well. We request you to also add play equipment for differently abled kids.

10. Library - We congratulate you on converting the beautiful building designed by the famous architect Otto Koenigsberger into a public library. It is benefiting a lot of people, but it must be maintained.


Thank you for your time and considering our requests. Look forward to your response and action.


Yours Sincerely,



Laxmi Nagaraj

Urban Planner & Architect

CC: Mr. Tushar Girinath, BBMP Commissioner

CC: Mr. Rakesh Singh, UCS, UDD


Links:

Recent Development

Due to the prompt attention to his matter by Priya Chetty-Rajagopal and her letters and telephone calls to the Horticulture Department and various agencies, Mr. Chandrasekhar, DD- BBMP Horticulture, promptly telephoned Heritage Beku regarding the above issue. He discussed our letter and concerns in detail with us. We thank him for his prompt attention to this matter. Here is what was discussed:

- The opening of all the entrances and extending the park hours in the afternoon will be reviewed

- A signal at the entrance on Dewan Madhav Rao Road for safe pedestrian crossing will be reviewed with the appropriate agencies

- Growing of appropriate plants in the Rose Garden area will be reviewed

- The railings were installed to make the park more inclusive to senior citizens.

Comment: The railings seem a little high. It would have been nice if the railing height was a little lower to meet the standard height for railings.

Some thoughts regarding the design for the Cantonment Railway Station Redevelopment.....

- The historical significance of the station and the heritage building are not important components of the redevelopment. The historic significance has not been given the importance it deserves.

- There are many excellent examples of redevelopment projects that have retained some important aspects of the historical structure (like an entrance, façade, portion of a building, roof etc.) along with the redevelopment. Here, no aspect of the heritage structure is retained or incorporated in the redevelopment design

- The context of the station (local context, materials, native landscaping, sustainability etc.) has not been given any consideration

- There is no information on whether public participation was considered for the redevelopment project

- The need to provide modern amenities and facilities is understandable, but it is not clear whether all the proposed amenities and facilities are need based

- It is not clear whether efforts have been made to preserve the existing trees


Via email

25/09/2022

Deputy Conservator of Forests and Tree Officer Bruhat Bangalore Mahanagara Palike, N.R. Square Annexe Building-3, Bangalore Phone: 9916649023

Email : dcfbbmp12@gmail.com

Dear Sir:

Re: Official Memorandum No. DCF/PR/1095/2022-23 dated 16/09/2022

We refer to the captioned Official Memorandum issued for removal of 60 roadside trees standing near the Radhakrishna Temple, Amarjyothi Layout, RMV 2nd stage, Ward No.18, Bangalore- 560094, for the purpose of widening a storm water drain.

We note a conflict of interest in this case as the trees are sought to be felled by the Assistant Executive Engineer, BBMP and the permission for tree felling is sought from the Deputy Conservator of Forests and Tree Officer, also from the BBMP. Legally it is important that a committee independent of the BBMP looks into the application for tree felling made by the Executive Engineer, BBMP. Therefore, the present Official Memorandum should be withdrawn, and an independent committee be constituted to look into the issue of tree felling for the project in question. It is submitted that there is absolutely no justification for the proposed tree felling, to widen a storm water drain. Trees by themselves serve as excellent ways and means to prevent flooding as they form a catchment area for rainwater and also improve the water table. They are as effective as storm water drains in preventing flooding and stagnation of water. Their action of trapping the rainwater also enriches the soil and helps improve its quality. In fact, by felling trees for widening a storm water drain, the flood situation will become worse as the area will lose valuable greenery which serves as an effective measure to prevent flooding.

In Writ Petition No.7288/2011 (Suo Moto versus Government of Karnataka and others), the High Court of Karnataka has directed that felling of trees be undertaken as an exception rather than a rule and further that the Tree Officer and Tree Authority would have to fully satisfy themselves and certify that all other alternatives have been considered regarding the feasibility of felling of trees, before permitting the felling of even a single tree.

As you are aware, pursuant to the judgment in the Public Interest Litigation petition filed by Dattatreya M Devare and Bangalore Environment Trust, the High Court of Karnataka ordered that the Tree Committee constituted should submit in writing the procedure and criteria for arriving at the number and type of trees to be axed and should issue its Report. Most importantly, whenever there is a proposal for felling of trees, the Expert Committee should examine whether the trees proposed to be felled could be saved by adopting any method and felling of trees should be considered only if it is found that after exhausting all methods, it is found that it is impossible to save any tree.impossible to save any tree.

The High Court has also opined that felling even one single tree could have an adverse impact on the environment, as once a tree is felled, it is permanently lost. In the present case, the criterion of public interest is certainly not fulfilled as felling the trees will lead to further damage to the environment and ecology and will in fact worsen the flood situation. Therefore, it is requested that the tree felling exercise for the purpose of widening the storm water drain be stopped immediately..

Thanking You, Yours Sincerely,

For Team Heritage Beku

Priya Chetty Rajagopal, Prabha Dev and Veena Krishnan



Blog: Blog

©2019 by #HeritageBeku.  All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page